Blogs

As the teacher shortage continues to impact schools nationwide, attracting and retaining substitute teachers has become a critical challenge. Here are five innovative strategies to boost substitute fill rates and ensure consistent, quality education.

1. Offer Teacher Preparation

Invest in substitute teachers’ professional development by providing:

• Essential classroom management techniques
• Strategies for adapting to curriculum and various teaching styles
• Familiarization with district policies and procedures

These programs could make substitute teaching more appealing and improve instruction quality.

2. Create Substitute Teacher Mentor Programs and Pathway Opportunities

Establish a support system for new substitute teachers and provide pathways to full-time teaching:

• Pair experienced educators with new substitutes
• Schedule regular check-ins and observations
• Provide opportunities to share experiences, challenges, and best practices
• Implement teacher pathway programs in partnership with local universities
• Offer on-the-job teaching experience while working towards a teaching degree

This approach can help substitutes feel connected to the school community, improve their classroom effectiveness, and create a clear path to full-time teaching positions.

3. Provide Recognition and Appreciation Opportunities

Recognizing and appreciating substitute teachers can be crucial for boosting morale, increasing retention, and fostering a positive school culture. Some opportunities you can provide for recognition include:

• Implement a “Substitute Teacher of the Month” program
• Create a wall of fame or digital showcase highlighting outstanding substitute teachers
• Encourage students and staff to write thank-you notes to exceptional substitutes

These strategies can help you create a more supportive and inclusive environment for substitute teachers, ultimately benefiting the entire school community.

4. Streamline the Application and Onboarding Process

Simplify hiring to make substitute teaching more accessible:

• Offer virtual interviews
• Provide clear guidelines on certification requirements
• Implement an efficient background check process

Removing unnecessary barriers can help to attract a wider pool of qualified candidates.

5. Feedback and Improvement Loop

Implementing a robust feedback and improvement system can also help you attract substitute teachers by enhancing their experience and demonstrating your school’s commitment to supporting its temporary staff. To implement a feedback system, you can:

• Regularly ask substitute teachers for opinions on their experiences
• Implement suggestions for improvement when feasible
• Share how their input has led to positive changes in the school

By showcasing this feedback system in your recruitment efforts, you can help to differentiate your school as an attractive workplace that cares about the needs of its substitute teachers.

Addressing the Broader Context

While these strategies focus on substitutes, it’s essential to recognize the larger issue affecting the teaching profession. School districts and policymakers must also address:

• Improving overall work conditions for teachers
• Reducing administrative burdens
• Investing in school infrastructure and resources
• Promoting respect for the teaching profession

By taking a holistic approach, we can create a more sustainable environment for both full-time and substitute teachers.

Implementing a combination of these five strategies can help improve your school or district’s ability to attract and retain qualified substitute teachers. By investing in substitutes and recognizing their value, we can create a more resilient education system that benefits students, teachers, schools, and communities alike.

Does your school or district need support in staffing substitute teachers? Learn how Amergis Educational Staffing can help.

Recent Highlights